According to Emily Deruy of The Atlantic, charter schools in Texas are best suited for ELL students rather than regular public schools. ELL in charter schools focus on fifty more days of learning in reading and twenty-two more days in math, compared to students in traditional public school systems (Deruy). Derby is not sure exactly why ELL students are succeeding, but she believes it has something to do with how focused charter schools are on helping ELL students, the amount of students living in poverty, and other underserved populations. There are far less public schools than charter schools, which may lead to students receiving more individualized support in the classroom
A teacher teaching two ELL students |
In her article in Times Magazine, Anne Raeff claims there is no algorithm to address the needs of all ELL students. She believes bilingual education, total immersion, and integrating cultural awareness are all part of the solution. New students, such as those classified as ELL, need extra support and a safe and nuturing academic community to make progress. Raeff's curriculum is flexible because of the students' backgrounds and diversity. She compromises with her learners current learning capabilites and builds off what they already know. Raeff's students made myriad amounts of progress, but they scored poorly on the standardized tests and their academic abilities were still far below their grade level. Raeff believes that there should be more vocational programs that allow students to take hands on courses in fields, such as mechanics and carpentry, for students who are not on track to go to college.
Students who are learning to speak English need time, support, and education from trained professionals. There is no blue print to teach ELL students English, every student learns differently and it is up to the teacher to figure out how that particular student will learn best.